Beyond Her: Safety Dynamics in Role-play AI Companions

Zehang Deng, Zhaoyang Xie, Changzhou Han, Hiran Thabrew, Wanlun Ma, Yue Huang, Jason, Xue, Sheng Wen, Tianqing Zhu, Yang Xiang

The film 'Her' pictured a future of love between humans and AI. That future has quietly emerged in the form of Role-play AI Companions (RACs), where emotionally responsive interactions blur the boundary between tool use and relational engagement. However, the safety implications remain poorly understood, as user experiences evolve over time through safety dynamics, spanning both emotional and risk behavioral dynamics, that can gradually shift interactions toward risk. In this paper, we investigate safety dynamics in RAC usage through a two-part mixed-methods study (Study I \& II). (1) Study I consists of semi-structured interviews (N = 16) to identify the key factors shaping these dynamics. We find that users' internalizing problems, the role personality adopted by the RAC, and risk interaction patterns jointly shape safety dynamics. Building on these insights, (2) Study II conducts a 14-day Ecological Momentary Assessment (N = 102) to examine how safety dynamics unfold in real-world usage. We identify distinct user profiles based on internalizing problems and show that interactions with RACs can produce short-term emotional relief while masking longer-term deterioration. Furthermore, vulnerable users exhibit more unstable risk behavioral patterns over time, making risk emergence less predictable and harder to mitigate with static safeguards. Our findings highlight the importance of modeling safety as a dynamic process rather than a static property. We conclude with three-layer design implications for next-generation AI companions, advocating for adaptive safeguards that can respond to evolving emotional and behavioral signals.