A Comparative Study on Machine Learning Methods for EEG-Based Human Emotion Recognition

Shokoufeh Davarzani, Simin Masihi, Masoud Panahi, Abdulrahman Olalekan Yusuf, Massood Atashbar

Electroencephalogram (EEG) signals provide a direct and non-invasive means of interpreting brain activity and are increasingly becoming valuable in embedded emotion-aware systems, particularly for applications in healthcare, wearable electronics, and human–machine interactions. Among various EEG-based emotion recognition techniques, deep learning methods have demonstrated superior performance compared to traditional approaches. This advantage stems from their ability to extract complex features—such as spectral–spatial connectivity, temporal dynamics, and non-linear patterns—from raw EEG data, leading to a more accurate and robust representation of emotional states and better adaptation to diverse data characteristics. This study explores and compares deep and shallow neural networks for human emotion recognition from raw EEG data, with the goal of enabling real-time processing in embedded and edge-deployable systems. Deep learning models—specifically convolutional neural networks (CNNs) and recurrent neural networks (RNNs)—have been benchmarked against traditional approaches such as the multi-layer perceptron (MLP), support vector machine (SVM), and k-nearest neighbors (kNN) algorithms. This comparative study investigates the effectiveness of deep learning techniques in EEG-based emotion recognition by classifying emotions into four categories based on the valence–arousal plane: high arousal, positive valence (HAPV); low arousal, positive valence (LAPV); high arousal, negative valence (HANV); and low arousal, negative valence (LANV). Evaluations were conducted using the DEAP dataset. The results indicate that both the CNN and RNN-STM models have a high classification performance in EEG-based emotion recognition, with an average accuracy of 90.13% and 93.36%, respectively, significantly outperforming shallow algorithms (MLP, SVM, kNN).